Resolution No. 37 – Case NC 388-11 – Inquiry by Conadecus regarding the concentration operation between LAN Airlines S.A. and TAM Linhas Aéreas S.A.

07/06/2016

The Competition Court, in a divided decision, approved the merger between LAN Airlines S.A. and TAM Linhas Aéreas S.A. (LAN and TAM, respectively), analyzed by this Tribunal because of an inquiry by Corporación Nacional de Consumidores y Usuarios de Chile (CONADECUS), subject to the following mitigation measures: (i) exchange of four of LAN or TAM’s daily slot pairs in Sao Paulo Guarulhos Airport, with airlines interested in starting or increasing regular air transportation services in the Santiago – Sao Paulo route; (ii) extension of LATAM’s Frequent Passenger Program benefits to passengers of an interested airline, for 5 years and in the terms indicated by the Tribunal; (iii) subscription of interline agreements in the Santiago – Sao Paulo, Santiago – Rio de Janeiro and/or Santiago – Asunción routes, with interested airlines who offer services in those routes; (iv) prohibition to increase the monthly supply of available seats in the Santiago – Sao Paulo route, in the period between 15 minutes before and 15 minutes after the flight itinerary of the exchanged slots; (v) modification of LAN’s Self-Regulation Plan, in the terms indicated in the Resolution; (vi) relinquishment of membership of at least one of the two global alliances to which LAN and TAM belong; (vii) elimination and revision of code sharing agreements with airlines that do not belong to the same global alliance as LATAM, in the indicated routes and intermediate routes; (viii) resignation by LAN of at least four 5th freedom right frequencies to Lima, in order for them to be reassigned to another Chilean airline, and restriction to LATAM’s participation in future frequency tenders; (ix) commitment by LAN to state its favorable opinion to a unilateral open skies policy for cabotage in Chile by foreign airlines, without reciprocity; (x) commitment to promote growth and the normal operation of the airports of Guarulhos (Sao Paulo) and Arturo Merino Benítez (Santiago), in order to ease access to other airlines; (xi) establishment of non-exclusionary commercialization conditions with distributors and travel agencies; LATAM cannot establish incentives or commissions based on its participation on total sales of the agent, or equivalents.

As long as LATAM hasn’t fully complied with the aforementioned condition (i), air fares for passenger and cargo transport in the routes Santiago – Sao Paulo and Santiago – Rio de Janeiro cannot be increased, and LATAM must maintain: (i) at least 12 weekly round trip flights in routes connecting Chile with USA, operated directly by LATAM; and (ii) at least 7 weekly round trip flights in routes connecting Chile with Europe, operated directly by LATAM. Lastly, LATAM must hire an independent third party, who will assist the National Prosecutor’s Office in the terms indicated in Condition XV, for the adequate monitoring of LATAM’s compliance to the aforementioned mitigation conditions.

This decision was agreed upon with a minority ruling by Judge Mr. Menchaca, who approved the operation without the conditions regarding: (i) the resignation of frequencies to Lima; and (ii) the prohibition to increase air fares for cargo transport. This, since the judge considered that those measures are not related to the effects of the Operation, and they were not discussed during the process.

Judge Mr. Velozo held a minority ruling. This judge was for rejecting the Operation, considering the following: (i) concentration of LAN with its closest competitor would consolidate a dominant carrier in Latin America, strengthening LAN’s power in the internal air market, with all the risks this implies for Chilean consumers; (ii) the possibility of timely and viable entry by companies who can challenge LATAM in air transport of passengers between Santiago and Brazil is reduced, and the mitigation conditions are not sufficient to revert that situation; (iii) entry of new airlines who compete with the merged company in most routs to and from Chile is not expected, given LATAM’s position in Santiago airport, and in its hubs in Lima and Sao Paulo; (iv) current competitors of LAN in Chile will probably connect with LATAM for the international segments of the trips they offer, which will favor cooperation relations instead of rivalry; (v) the merged company will be able, by itself, to establish new barriers to entry and expansion of competitors, via strategic behavior, and will have significant incentives to do so; (vi) the consolidation of a regional duopoly may increase risks of coordinated conducts that tend to allocate the market, with the implied negative consequences for Chilean consumers: (vii) this Judge does not consider prudent to authorize a merger of this magnitude as long as there are no substantial advances in the liberalization of this industry in South America, and he considers that the merger may be harmful for said deregulation; (viii) the companies that wish to merge have not demonstrated in which way does the Operation benefit consumers in the national and international passenger air transport markets, nor have they demonstrated how the efficiencies they intend to reach will not be an obstacle to competition; (ix) the cost savings or productive efficiency gains LAN is pursuing could be reached in ways that impose less risks to competition, such as merging with a South American actor apart from TAM, or deepening or broadening its commercial agreements with other airlines in the region; (x) the substantial increment of LAN’s market power that this Operation will cause, will not be effectively controllable by Chilean competition authorities. For all these reasons, the dissident Judge concludes that the most cost-effective way to preserve competition is not authorizing this merger.

Noticias Relacionadas

17/06/2024

TDLC llama a concurso público para proveer cargo de Asistente Administrativo/a

TDLC llama a concurso público para proveer cargo de Asistente Administrativo/a Conforme lo dispuesto en el Decreto Ley Nº 211, el Tribunal de Defensa de la Libre Competencia llama a concurso de antecedentes y oposición para proveer el cargo de: ASISTENTE ADMINISTRATIVO asimilado a grado 16°, plazo fijo hasta el 31 de diciembre de 2024, […]

17/06/2024

Presidente del TDLC, Nicolás Rojas C., participó en Comité de Competencia de la OCDE

El Presidente del TDLC, Nicolás Rojas C., participó en las distintas reuniones del Comité de Competencia de la OCDE y de sus grupos de trabajo que se realizaron entre el lunes 10 y viernes 14 de junio en París. El Comité de Competencia de la OCDE es un foro de análisis de la política de […]

13/06/2024

TDLC informa sobre eventual intermitencia en ClaveÚnica por actualización de su plataforma

De acuerdo con lo informado por la Secretaría de Gobierno Digital, informamos a nuestros/as usuarios/a que debido a una actualización en la plataforma ClaveÚnica, ésta podría presentar intermitencia o interrupción entre el 13 de junio y el 19 del junio, desde las 20:00 hasta las 23.59 horas. Si nuestros/as usuarios/a presentaran alguna dificultad para ingresar […]

12/06/2024

El TDLC informa sobre nueva funcionalidad en la Oficina Judicial Virtual relacionada con el retiro de copias autorizadas de escritos en expedientes

El Tribunal informa a sus usuarios/as que, a partir de hoy, está operativa una nueva funcionalidad en la Oficina Judicial Virtual (OJV) relacionada con el retiro de copias autorizadas de escritos en expedientes. Esta nueva funcionalidad, dirigida a usuarios/as con perfil de abogado/a, habilitado/a en derecho y usuario/a general, la encontrarán en el expediente respectivo […]

11/06/2024

Consejo del Banco Central designa ministra titular abogada y ministro titular economista para conformar el Pleno del TDLC

Con fecha 10 de junio de 2024, el Consejo del Banco Central designó a Silvia Retamales Morales, como nueva ministra titular abogada y a Ignacio Parot Morales como nuevo ministro titular economista, quienes deberán cumplir sus funciones por un período de seis años. Silvia Retamales M., es abogada de la Universidad de Chile y realizó […]

05/06/2024

Causa Rol NC N° 525-23: TDLC fija fecha de audiencia pública en causa caratulada “Solicitud de Informe sobre rebaja al límite de la potencia indicado en el literal d) del artículo 147° de la Ley General de Servicios Eléctricos” para el 17 de julio de 2024.

En los autos Rol NC N° 525-23 caratulados “Solicitud de Informe sobre rebaja al límite de la potencia indicado en el literal d) del artículo 147° de la Ley General de Servicios Eléctricos”, el Tribunal de Defensa de Libre Competencia dictó con fecha 4 de junio de 2024 la resolución que fija como fecha para […]

04/06/2024

TDLC informa las instrucciones de acceso a la vista de la causa Rol NC N° 529-24 caratulada “Consulta de Sociedad Verallia Chile S.A. sobre las bases de licitación para la venta de residuos de envases y embalajes para su valorización de la Corporación Sistema Colectivo de Gestión de Envases y Embalajes ReSimple”.

Mañana miércoles 5 de junio de 2024, a las 9:30 horas, tendrá lugar la audiencia de la causa Rol NC N° 529-24 caratulada “Consulta de Sociedad Verallia Chile S.A. sobre las bases de licitación para la venta de residuos de envases y embalajes para su valorización de la Corporación Sistema Colectivo de Gestión de Envases y Embalajes ReSimple”, la que […]

03/06/2024

Leonardo Moreno Zanetti, ingeniero civil industrial, asume como Analista de Procesos grado 12° en el Tribunal de Defensa de la Libre Competencia.

Leonardo Moreno Z., es ingeniero civil industrial de la Universidad Técnica Federico Santa María. Se desempeñó como ingeniero en gestión de operaciones en Multicaja (Klap) donde lideró diferentes proyectos para la Gerencia de Operaciones, entre ellos, levantamiento de procesos relevantes para la empresa, desarrollo y control de indicadores de gestión para la Gerencia. Asimismo, trabajó […]